10 Things to Consider When Choosing a Dog Toy

10 Things to Consider When Choosing a Dog Toy

Choosing the right toys for your dog is crucial for their health, safety, and overall happiness. 

Dog toys are not merely objects for play; they are essential tools for mental stimulation, physical exercise, and emotional bonding. 

In this article, we outline the 10 key considerations for selecting the perfect dog toy, along with tips and best practices to ensure your furry friend stays safe and engaged.


1. Material Safety

Choose toys made from non-toxic, pet-safe materials. 

Dogs tend to chew vigorously, and harmful chemicals in poorly manufactured toys can lead to poisoning or severe health issues. 

Look for certifications or labels that indicate the toy’s safety standards, such as BPA-free or phthalate-free labels for plastic or rubber toys.


Risks of ignoring this: Toxic materials can cause gastrointestinal issues, allergic reactions, or poisoning. 

Ingesting unsafe toys may require emergency veterinary intervention. Long-term exposure can lead to chronic illnesses like liver or kidney damage.


2. Durability

Assess your dog’s chewing habits and select toys that can withstand their strength.

Heavy chewers, like larger breeds, need robust toys made from durable materials such as rubber or nylon.

Reinforced stitching in plush toys or layered construction in chew toys enhances durability.


Risks of ignoring this: Fragile toys can break apart, posing a choking hazard or causing intestinal blockages. 

Frequent replacements can become costly, and your dog might associate play with frustration.


3. Size Appropriateness

Ensure the toy’s size matches your dog’s breed and age.

A toy too small can be swallowed, while an oversized toy might not interest smaller breeds. 

Opt for toys slightly larger than your dog’s mouth to prevent accidental swallowing.


Risks of ignoring this: Toys that are too small can lead to choking or intestinal blockages.

Oversized toys may be unusable, causing frustration and disinterest, which can decrease physical activity.


4. Purpose of the Toy

Identify what you want the toy to achieve: mental stimulation, physical exercise, or comfort. 

Puzzle toys, fetch toys, and comfort items serve different purposes. 

Puzzle toys can prevent cognitive decline in older dogs, while fetch toys encourage cardio exercise.


Risks of ignoring this: Choosing an inappropriate toy may result in boredom or behavioral issues like excessive chewing or barking. 

Dogs may seek stimulation from household items, leading to destructive habits.


5. Ease of Cleaning

Toys can harbor bacteria, especially if frequently used outdoors or involve treats. 

Look for washable toys or those made with antimicrobial materials. 

Dishwasher-safe toys are an excellent option for convenience.


Risks of ignoring this: Unclean toys can cause bacterial infections and other health concerns for your dog. 

Dirty toys may emit unpleasant odors, making them less appealing.


6. Supervised vs. Unsupervised Play

Some toys are suitable only for supervised play, especially if they’re prone to breaking into small parts. 

Always read the manufacturer’s guidelines. Supervision is crucial with new toys until you are confident in their durability and safety.


Risks of ignoring this: Unattended play with unsuitable toys can lead to choking, injury, or ingestion of hazardous materials. 

Emergency surgeries to remove swallowed parts can be traumatic and expensive.


7. Type of Chewer

Every dog has a different chewing style. 

Gentle chewers may do well with plush toys, while aggressive chewers need indestructible options. 

Toys labeled for "power chewers" are ideal for dogs that shred toys quickly.


Risks of ignoring this: Soft toys given to aggressive chewers may result in rapid destruction and ingestion of harmful materials like stuffing or squeakers, leading to digestive issues or requiring surgical intervention.


8. Age of the Dog

Puppies have different needs than adult or senior dogs. 

Puppies benefit from teething toys, while seniors may prefer softer options for sensitive teeth. 

Cooling teething toys can soothe sore gums.


Risks of ignoring this: Toys unsuitable for a dog’s age may result in disinterest, dental damage, or inadequate stimulation. 

For example, senior dogs may struggle with hard chew toys, while teething puppies may ignore non-teething-specific options.


9. Interactive Features

Toys with interactive features, like treat dispensers or sound-making capabilities, keep dogs engaged longer. 

These are especially useful for dogs left alone for extended periods. Puzzle toys improve problem-solving skills.


Risks of ignoring this: Without engaging toys, dogs can become bored, leading to destructive behavior like chewing furniture or digging. 

High-energy breeds may develop anxiety without adequate stimulation.


10. Brand Reputation and Reviews

Purchase toys from reputable brands known for quality and safety. 

Online reviews provide insights into how well a toy performs. Look for reviews discussing durability, safety, and suitability for specific breeds or sizes.


Risks of ignoring this: Cheap or unverified toys may not meet safety standards, leading to potential hazards and wasted money. 

Trusted brands often offer customer support or replacement guarantees if issues arise.


Types of Toys to Consider

Chew Toys – Ideal for dental health and teething puppies. Examples include KONG toys or flavored nylon bones.


Interactive Toys – Puzzle toys and treat dispensers keep dogs mentally engaged and reduce separation anxiety.


Fetch Toys – Balls or frisbees encourage physical exercise. Glow-in-the-dark options work for nighttime play.


Plush Toys – Offer comfort, especially to gentle chewers or young puppies. Opt for reinforced stitching.


Rope Toys – Great for tug-of-war and dental health, but ensure durability and minimal loose fibers.


Precautions to Take

Regularly inspect toys for wear and tear. Discard damaged toys to prevent injuries.

Avoid toys with small detachable parts for larger dogs.

Rotate toys periodically to maintain interest and excitement.


Consequences of Ignoring Precautions

If you overlook these factors, your dog may face serious health risks, including:

Choking or gastrointestinal blockages from ingesting parts of the toy.

Exposure to harmful chemicals causing long-term health issues.

Behavioral problems from inadequate mental and physical stimulation.

Dental damage from unsuitable toys.


By carefully selecting the right toys and taking precautions, you’ll ensure your dog’s safety and happiness.

Observing your dog’s preferences and adapting choices as their needs evolve will create a joyful and enriching playtime experience. 

Make informed choices for your pet’s well-being and ensure their playtime is as safe as it is fun.

So far, we have looked at 10 things to keep in mind when choosing a dog toy. I hope this article was of some help to those who are raising dogs, and I would appreciate it if you could share this article with those who need it.